Jorge is getting ripped off and other ASG thoughts
Well the 2007 All Star Game balloting first vote tally's are in and there are some surprises and disappointments involved...
Currently New York Yankees back stop Jorge Posada is number 4 in the AL Catcher category. I don't
have any idea how this could be possible. I know that the All Star Game selection is basically a glorified popular contest and I know that in the past there have been the New York Yankees players who have won these ballots despite the fact the didn't have the numbers to back up the votes.
Maybe this is payback for those All Star Selections in years past.
But I honestly don't see how you can defend Posada being 4th behind on the vote.
I mean if you look at the standings and numbers Jorge is ahead of all the other AL Catchers in batting average. He's almost 50 points higher than number one vote getter Ivan Rodriguez and Posada's .357 average currently leads all AL and all NL players for the best average for any player in the majors.
Posada also leads AL catchers in slugging percentage, total bases, games played, doubles, hits, runs scored, and is second in homers and RBI's.
Posada leads catchers in 6 separate offensive categories...
(click on this or any of the other stat graphs to view and easier to read full size version...)
I might understand if Posada was 2nd in the voting or if it was a close vote --- but what are All Star voters looking at to have him ranked 4th and over 72 thousand votes behind I-Rod?
Now I looked at the rest of the AL vote leaders for 2007 as well and right now Giambi is 2nd in the 1B vote and Cano is first in the 2B vote and honestly neither of them deserves to be ranked that high.
At this moment Morneau is heading towards being 400 thousand votes behind Ortiz in first place and Giambi in 2nd place even though between Ortiz, Giambi, and Hafner they've only played 5 games at first base combined ( zero for Ortiz, 3 for Hafner, and 2 for Giambi.
As much as I don't like Youkilis, he's got the 2nd highest batting average behind Posada in the American League and is only one home run behind Ortiz and just 8 RBI's behind him while having a 39 point lead on Ortiz in batting average. Youkilis also has 8 more total bases, 2 more steals, 14 more hits, and 4 more runs scored.
Then Carlos Pena has one more homer and a .300 batting average.
There are 4 or 5 AL 1B's with a batting average about .300 --- so to have Giambi as the number two vote getter seems wrong.
Especially considering he doesn't play first base anymore.
This is the 1B All Star ballot, not the DH ballot.
I know there isn't a DH category since we are playing in an NL Park in the 2007 ASG...
But that doesn't mean that 1B's don't get to play in the AL and shouldn't be recognized.
Maybe the ASG should be played under AL rules EVERY year no matter if the game is played in an NL or an AL park so that the AL 1B's can get voted on due to 1B merit.
Or maybe in the years that the game is played in an NL park and under NL rules there should be a "Pinch Hitter" category instead of a "Designated Hitter" category?
And lastly, with the AL second baseman vote I think there is a slightly questionable vote going on...
Cano has the lead in the second base voting despite the fact that he has 2 home runs and a .264 batting average. Polanco and Roberts are both worthy selections with a .330 and a .310 batting average respectively. My choice would be Brian Roberts who's hitting .310 with 85 total bases 34 walks, and 19 stolen bases. At this point in the season Roberts is on pace for 60 steals, 110 walks, and a + 300 average with 50 or 60 RBI's and 10-15 homers. That's a lot of speed and production from your 2B.
So I think Jeter, Rodriguez, and Posada deserve to go to the 2007 ASG in San Francisco and perhaps Cano or one of our outfielders will deserve it before the voting is over.
But right now I think Posada is getting screwed and that it's a travesty that Youkilis, Morneau and Roberts are getting screwed out of being AL ASG starters.
Well that's my thoughts on this situation for now.
I know it's early and votes will still be tallied and reported weekly for the next month.
But early returns are disappointing to me and perhaps to you as well.
Any thoughts?
Mike




































































































